A recent story on 60 Minutes was fascinating Abundance With Money Review and disturbing. The biggest traders on Wall Street are no longer humans representing Brokerage Houses, but uber-speed computers. These electronic traders do not require human intervention to execute their trades, but rely on pre-programmed instructions based on complex algorithms. The trader - in this case the computer - has no equity expertise and does not know the underlying value of the companies or their stocks. It can make thousands of decisions and execute thousands of trades within micro-seconds. What the computer lacks in fundamental knowledge it more than makes up for in rapidity of trade execution and analysis of trends.
Now some would argue this is old news. The NASDAQ (National Association of Securities Dealers Automated) has been electronic and automated for decades. In contrast, despite its prominence, the New York Stock Exchange was viewed as a quaint equities anachronism using color-coded employees, hand signals, telephones and slips of paper. And although the 60 Minutes piece was broadcast in 2011, some form of High Frequency Trading (HFT) has been around for at least a decade. Of course the sophistication of the technology and the decisions based on mathematical models has improved exponentially.
On the surface this new methodology appears superior. It is fast, cost-effective, not prone to human order-entry error, not subject to emotion, and facilitates trades at the best possible price. It represents another example of the wonders of technology. However, as Lesley Stahl, CBS reporter discovered, high frequency trading has some very vocal critics, as well as some powerful advocates.
The biggest problem in HFT may be the disconnect between investing based on actual (fundamental) value vs. excessive trading based on ever-changing price-points over exceptionally brief periods. Because of the volume of synchronized trades the High Frequency Traders can become market makers and movers creating erratic or distorted volume and price moves. Some blame the 2010 "Flash Crash" on HFT. From another viewpoint, HFT actually minimizes market volatility and has a leveling effect because the moves in or out of advancing or declining equities is so efficient.
- Aaliawilliam's blog
- Log in or register to post comments